I
am currently not a member of any paranormal investigation group, but I have
gone on ghost hunts before. Sometimes I
went with just a handful of likeminded friends, and sometimes I was an
investigator with a formal group. On one occasion I participated in a multiple organization
collaboration hunt. I was invited to join one of these groups, but the distance
between them and myself would make regular participation impossible. However, I
still worked with them as a guest investigator when possible and reviewed
evidence as my schedule permitted. I have worked with dedicated enthusiasts as
well as weekend hobbyists. I have used audio recorders, video recorders, white
noise machines, ghost boxes, EMF meters, K2 meters, and laser grids among a few
other gadgets. These investigations took me to some very creepy locations and
even a couple of places of historical significance.
I
mention the above not to brag, but rather to show you the perspective I come
from when I speak about paranormal investigations. I cannot say that I am some
expert with hundreds of cases from which to speak. At the same time, I have
been a little more involved in the paranormal than just watching ghost shows on
TV. So, with all of that in mind, I present the following question:
Is
ghost hunting a science?
I
am doubtful, at least not the way we view it today.
I
believe that many, but certainly not all, investigators conflate what they do
with scientific research and experimentation and I understand why. An
investigator uses special equipment, collects data, and uses that data to reach
a conclusion. However, this all lacks a few key components of scientific
experimentation. I considered using this post to go through a step by step analysis
of the scientific method and pointing out the many deficiencies in its common
application, or really lack thereof, to paranormal investigation. I even got a
good way through writing it, but ended up hitting the delete key. It was
turning into a post too large to handle with my limited time today. Plus, while
I do have some background in soft sciences and research, I am not a scientist.
Here are just the big points instead:
Investigations
are not done in a controlled setting. Yes, investigators (hopefully) do
everything they can to minimize or at least mark contaminations be they audio,
video, or atmospheric related. I don't think that is enough. If it was maybe
one contamination, that would be one thing. It is never one thing, not if we
are being honest. There are layers and layers of data contamination and, absent
a sterile setting and taking special precautions, you cannot objectively rule
out these flaws in the process. To the outsider looking in, there would always
be another explanation for the results and that explanation would probably be
more reasonable. Was that an EVP in the background of the audio or the steps of
an investigator? Did a ghost push the ball or was there a draft? Was that an
orb or a bug? There are just too many holes in the process to give objective
validity to the evidence.
The
evidence is not repeatable. Yes, you can go to the same place on different
nights and find different things, but can you precisely repeat your finding
under the exact same conditions within an acceptable margin of error? I'm not
talking about sensations or feelings. Can you directly replicate the same
evidence hundreds of times in that hypothetical sterile environment? I've never
seen it. Until the investigation, or experiment if we are following the
scientific method, can be replicated with precision, this area will never be
considered a science. In terms of statistical analysis, the experiment has no,
or at least insufficient, reliability.
So
how would I characterize all of the experiences of investigators and the
evidence they collect?
Anecdotal.
It
is almost always directly tied to the personal experiences of the investigator.
Even the otherwise objective evidence is subjective in the broad view of the
investigation. For example, someone records an EVP of a whisper that sounds a
lot like "I killed her." It is definitely very creepy. It gives goose
bumps to everyone that hears it. It is still anecdotal to the person that recorded it. It is most likely a
very soft sound only heard because the audio reviewer listened to the recording
wearing headphones with the volume turned up high. Could it be the shuffle of
someone's feet? An exhale of someone's breath? Shifting in floorboards? Wood
contracting or expanding due to temperature? A distant animal, insect, or
vehicle? Unless you were there at that moment when it was recorded, you cannot
rule out contamination. Therefore, it is anecdotal to that investigator.
This post is not to denigrate investigators and
it is not to say people should not explore the paranormal. It is a fascinating
subject matter and I go on investigations whenever possible. If
you are so inclined, go. Explore, peer into the dark, and records what you find
there. I do every chance I get. However, we all must be honest with ourselves
about what we are, and are not, doing.
If paranormal investigating is not science, in
my opinion, then what is it? If not to produce solid verifiable evidence of
ghosts, why do we do it? Let's save those questions for another day.
L.S. Michaels